• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Cagle Diaries logo

menu icon
go to homepage
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Recipes
  • Contact Us
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Recipes
  • Contact Us
×
Home » Recipes » Dessert Recipes

Amish Peanut Butter Pie


Prep Time :15 minutes mins
Cook Time :25 minutes mins
Total Time :40 minutes mins
Servings :8
Jump to Recipe
A slice of Amish Peanut Butter Pie on a plate with the pie dish behind.
A long collage with two images showing Amish peanut butter pie, the first image is of the whole pie. The second image is of just a slice of that pie.

Published: May 21, 2023 · Modified: May 15, 2025 by Melanie Cagle · Leave a Comment

This decadent and silky Amish Peanut Butter Pie recipe is one for the books. Layers of sweet creaminess, it's all your sweet tooth has been waiting for.

A slice of Amish Peanut Butte rPie with a pie dish behind.
Amish Peanut Butter Pie
Save Recipe

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

Enter your email below and we'll send you the recipe straight to your inbox (and more recipes sent periodically!)


It's a dessert that can pretty much be made year round as it's not dependent on any seasonal produce or anything like that.

It is pretty special though, so works great for things like Thanksgiving desserts or Christmas. Or even just to a dinner party.

Jump to:
  • What makes this recipe so yummy
  • Groceries you'll need: Ingredients
  • Recipe walkthrough: Instructions
  • Recipe variations and substitute ideas
  • Necessary gear: Equipment
  • More pie recipes I think you'll love
  • How to store leftovers
  • Mel's kitchen notes
  • Melanie Cagle
  • Frequently asked questions: FAQs
  • Amish Peanut Butter Pie Recipe
  • 💬 Comments

What makes this recipe so yummy

  • In the traditional Amish recipe way, few easy to source ingredients are needed to make this pie.
  • I love that I make mine using a homemade Amish Pie Crust - you could use a store-bought crust though, with no issues.
  • Other than the pie crust needing to be blind-baked, this is a no bake dessert. Don't you love easy recipes?
  • If you have a peanut butter lover (like my kids) they will LOVE this pie.
  • It's a great dessert on a hot summer day.
  • It's a decadent dessert for peanut butter lovers.

Groceries you'll need: Ingredients

Ingredients needed to make an Amish peanut butter pie with text overlay.

See recipe card at the bottom of this post for quantities.

Recipe walkthrough: Instructions

This is an overview of the recipe steps. For more detailed instructions visit the recipe card at the bottom of this post.

  • Step 1: Blind bake your pie crust then let it cool.
  • Step 2: In the bowl of a stand mixer (or electric mixer) add the peanut butter and powdered sugar and mix using the whisk attachment. It will form little pebble like balls.
  • Step 3: Take half of the peanut butter crumbs and pour into the bottom of the pie shell. Move around to even out.
  • Step 4: Wash the bowl of your stand mixer then add the heavy cream. Whip using the whisk attachment until soft peaks form. Add some powdered sugar and whip again until you get stiff peaks.
A slice of Amish peanut butter pie being lifted out of the pie dish.
  • Step 5: Remove most of the whipped cream and set aside in another medium bowl, leaving 1 cup of whipping cream.
  • Step 6: Add peanut butter, instant pudding mix and cold milk. Using the paddle attachment slowly mix the ingredients until totally combined.
  • Step 7: Pour pudding into the pie dish on top of the peanut butter crumbles. Smooth out with a spatula.
  • Step 8: Spoon the remaining whipped cream on top (or pipe on using a piping bag if you want it prettier) then sprinkle the remaining peanut butter pebbles (crumb mixture) on top of pie. Place in the refrigerator to firm up before serving.

Hint: I tend to add just the 2 tablespoons of peanut butter to the pudding mix. Any more and it can be too heavy on the peanut butter taste. If you want it to be less rich, perhaps use 1 tablespoon or leave it out of the pudding altogether.

Recipe variations and substitute ideas

  • Cool Whip - instead of homemade whipped cream use cool whip whipped topping.
  • Egg Yolks - do the homemade vanilla pudding thing - with the egg yolks and vanilla bean.
  • Cream Cheese - using cream cheese in the peanut butter filling, is an option.
  • Chocolate Chips - These could be scattered if you want to add that texture.
  • Store bought pie crust - instead of a traditional pie crust.
  • Crunchy Peanut Butter - some people like to use crunchy peanut butter. It's an option.
  • Graham Cracker Crust - Try using a graham cracker crust instead.
  • Brown Sugar - you could try mixing the peanut butter with brown sugar instead.
  • Egg Whites - you could whip some up and add a meringue.
  • Cornstarch - you could add a little cornstarch mixture if you like it firmer.
  • Oreo Cookie Crust - you could try this - it sounds like it could work.
  • Chocolate Shavings - chocolate and peanut butter go so well together. Sprinkle some chocolate shavings on top.
A full overhead view of a peanut butter pie with peanut butter sprinkles on top.

Sharing is Caring - Like Our Facebook Page

The Cagle Diaries

Necessary gear: Equipment

The following are affiliate links. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

When making this Amish peanut butter pie I like to use my stand mixer. It makes life so much quicker. A hand mixer is also just as good.

You'll also need a 9" pie dish. I have some affiliate links in the recipe card below.

More pie recipes I think you'll love

  • Overhead shot of a sweet potato pie with swirls of cream.
    Grandma's Sweet Potato Pie Recipe
  • Close up of a slice of white pumpkin pie being taken out of a pie dish.
    White Pumpkin Pie
  • a plate with a slice of pecan pie with a ball of ice cream sitting on top
    Old Fashioned Pecan Pie
  • close up of an Amish pumpkin pie with a fork having just taken a piece from the front of the pie - a dollop of cream on top
    Amish Pumpkin Pie Recipe
  • Country Apple Pie
  • Southern Lemon Pie Recipe
  • No Bake Cherry Pie with Graham Cracker Crust
  • Nutella Trifle
  • Southern Peach Cobbler Recipe With Pie Crust
  • Cracker Barrel Buttermilk Pie Recipe
  • Rice Pudding With Evaporated Milk
  • No Bake Snickers Pie
  • Amish Fudge Recipe
  • Old Fashioned Chess Pie
  • Raspberry Pie

If you're a big fan of Amish recipes, you should also try my Amish Mashed Potatoes, they're amazing.

How to store leftovers

This dessert should be stored in the refrigerator. In an airtight container or covered with plastic wrap.

Mel's kitchen notes

To keep the cream on top a little firmer you can add a little vanilla pudding mix, while whipping it. Just about a tablespoon or so. It will help prevent the cream topping from melting/wilting.

About The Author

Melanie Cagle

Melanie is a professional cook, food photographer and Cajun food connoisseur. Since 2020 she has been sharing rigorously tested recipes and tutorials right here on this blog.

Her work has been featured on Fox News channels, Yahoo news, Southern Living and more.

About Mel
A slice of peanut butter pie with the front piece sliced out.

Frequently asked questions: FAQs

What is in Amish Peanut Butter?

Yes, Amish peanut butter is slightly different. It has marshmallow creme and corn syrup added. I don't use that kind of peanut butter for this pie. Just the regular store bought version.

What makes this an Amish recipe?

There's no steadfast rule when it comes to Amish recipes, this peanut butter cream pie is a traditional pie often sold though. You'll typically find that their recipes will be as few ingredients as possible, simplified and easy to source ingredients. It's always SO GOOD though.

I don't have a pie crust recipe, can you recommend one?

Most definitely. I actually have an Amish Pie Crust recipe right here.


If you’ve tried this Amish Peanut Butter Pie Recipe or any other great recipe on my site, let me know in the comment section below, how it turned out, we love hearing from our readers!

If you love this recipe please give it 5 stars! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

You can also follow me on PINTEREST, FACEBOOK and INSTAGRAM to see more amazing recipes!

a loaf tin with banana bread with mayo on a cooling rack

Viral Recipe Alert!

Banana Bread

Due to the secret ingredient in this deliciously moist banana bread it has become one of my most sought after recipes!

Get the recipe
A slice of Amish Peanut Butter Pie on a plate with the pie dish behind.
Print (Email Required)

Amish Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

A decadent and silky peanut butter pie, a recipe made famous by the Amish. Layers of peanut butter pebbles, vanilla pudding and topped with a whipped cream and more peanut butter pebbles.
Prep Time15 minutes mins
Cook Time25 minutes mins
Total Time40 minutes mins
Servings: 8
Cuisine: Dessert
Author: Melanie Cagle
Prevent your screen from going dark

Equipment

  • 9" Pie Dish
  • Stand Mixer

Ingredients

  • 1 Each Pie Crust Recipe
  • 10 Tablespoons Creamy Peanut Butter divided
  • 1 Cup Powdered Sugar
  • 3 Cups Heavy Whipping Cream divided
  • 1 (3.4 Ounce) Box Instant French Vanilla Pudding Mix
  • 1 Cup Whole Milk

Instructions

  • Blind bake your pie crust then allow to cool.
    1 Each Pie Crust Recipe
  • Add ½ Cup Peanut Butter to the bowl of your stand mixer (or a mixing bowl with a hand mixer) along with the cup of powdered sugar, mix using the whisk attachment until little pebbles have formed.
    10 Tablespoons Creamy Peanut Butter, 1 Cup Powdered Sugar
  • Take half of this mixture and add to the bottom of the cooled pie crust, evenly. Set aside the rest as they will be used as topping.
  • Clean the mixing bowl and add the cream. Whip with the whisk attachment then add the ¼ Cup of powdered sugar to the cream and whip again until stiff peaks have formed.
    3 Cups Heavy Whipping Cream
  • Remove most of the cream to another bowl, leaving 1 cup. Add the pudding mix, milk and 2 tablespoons of peanut butter and mix on low using the paddle attachment. Just do this until incorporated then pour into the pie dish on top of the peanut butter pebbles. Smooth out using a spatula.
    1 (3.4 Ounce) Box Instant French Vanilla Pudding Mix, 1 Cup Whole Milk, 10 Tablespoons Creamy Peanut Butter
  • Take the remaining cream that you set aside and layer on top of the pudding layer. You could also use a piping bag if you want it to look pretty.
  • Sprinkle the remaining peanut butter pebbles on top of the cream.
  • Put into the refrigerator to firm up before serving.
Did You Make This?Please consider Leaving a Review!

Nutrition

Serving: 1g | Calories: 575kcal | Carbohydrates: 34g | Protein: 8g | Fat: 47g | Saturated Fat: 25g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 18g | Trans Fat: 1g | Cholesterol: 104mg | Sodium: 382mg | Fiber: 2g | Sugar: 21g

Sign Up for my emails and never miss another recipe!

I'll never share your email, or send you spam. Pinkie Promise!

More Dessert Recipes

  • An old fashioned hummingbird cake with some slices removed, the image is cropped square.
    Old Fashioned Hummingbird Cake Recipe
  • A dish with old fashioned cherry delight, with some squares missing and a spatula laying inside.
    Old Fashioned Cherry Delight Recipe
  • Close up of the top of a country apple pie recipe.
    Country Apple Pie Recipe
  • two tacos stuffed with banana pudding
    Banana Pudding Tacos
237 shares
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Email

Filed Under: Amish Recipes, Christmas, Dessert Recipes, Pie Recipes, Southern Recipes, Thanksgiving

Reader Interactions

Comments

No Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating





Primary Sidebar

Momma Cagle!

Picture of Melanie Cagle standing in front of her stove, in the kitchen.

I'm Melanie, I am mom to two beautiful children and married to James - my American sweetheart (I'm British).  A transplant in Houma, South Louisiana I have found a love for all Cajun and Creole food.
Learn more about me...

CAJUN FAVORITES

  • Bowl of crawfish etouffee with rice scoop in the middle.
    Cajun Crawfish Etouffee
  • Close up of boudin balls with a hint of the mustard cream sauce peeking in, sprinkled with green onions on top.
    Deep Fried Boudin Balls
  • A tray of boiled crabs with veggies and dipping sauce.
    Authentic Louisiana Crab Boil Recipe: Spicy Cajun Seafood Feast
  • Close up of a bowl of seafood gumbo with a pile of rice and a spoon digging into it.
    Authentic Louisiana Seafood Gumbo Recipe
  • A large platter of fried catfish nuggets with some lemon wedges and a tartar sauce.
    Fried Catfish Nuggets
  • Close up of some pinto beans and sausage on a spoon over a crock pot.
    Crock Pot Pinto Beans

Footer

↑ back to top

About

as seen on logo images

Terms & Conditions | Accessibility Policy | Contact

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

©2025 Copyright The Cagle Diaries. All rights reserved.

Rate This Recipe

Your vote:




A rating is required
A name is required
An email is required